Skip To Content

Best Pizza Shops in York

No type of food is as universally satisfying and cravable as a freshly baked pizza using only the purest ingredients. In York, PA, you can find a variety of pizza joints celebrating their unique take on this loved classic, finding inspiration in classically New York thin-style crusts, to thick and authentic Sicilian or modern, artisanal pizza blends with one-of-a-kind flavors and combinations.

Every York resident has their favorite pizza spot — here are five shops where you can find the best piping hot pizza places near you.

Pizza Pie


1. Brewvino

If you’re looking for the perfect joint to catch the Sunday NFL games or hang with your closest friends, then Brewvino near Peoples Bank Park is the ideal gathering place for you. With a specially selected list of craft beers and wine, perfect for pairing with their $15 large handcrafted specialty pizzas, you can have a fun and memorable night with your favorite people and meal. The staff is extremely friendly and knowledgeable about the best toppings and beer combinations to have an unforgettable savory meal.

Root for your favorite team this Sunday with a cold one and a slice at Brewvino located at 251 N. George St, home of the York Revolution.

2. DiCarlo’s Pizza

Head to downtown York for a truly delicious and unique pizza devouring experience. Like many other pizzas crafted throughout York, DiCarlo’s Pizza uses fresh ingredients to create herby sauces and crispy, chewy crusts shaped into a distinct square shape. What makes DiCarlo’s Pizza one of the best pizzas in York is that they place the cheese on after the pizza has been cooked. While having the cheese pulled away from the rest of the pie is an iconic image for pizza, by using


cold cheese, you actually have a smoother, creamier and sharper flavor — and avoid pesky cheese burns on the roof of your mouth.

To experience a truly different type of pizza, visit DiCarlo’s Pizza at 24 N. George St.

3. Pizza Al Bacio

Anyone who has had a thick crust, square Sicilian pizza knows the flavors and textures of this unique pie are unforgettable. Pizza Al Bacio is York’s most authentic pizza crafted from Sicilian natives using only the purest ingredients, including ripe California tomatoes and crust that’s rolled out fresh daily, leaving you a chewy and savory pizza slice that melts in your mouth.

Find York’s Sicilian hidden gem at 555 Ryan Run Road — enjoy the best Sicilian pizza for a reasonably priced lunch or dinner, and don’t forget to add a cannoli for dessert.

4. Primo Pizza Express

When you’re looking for the best pizza places near York, PA, then stop at Primo Pizza Express to experience a bit of everything — a clean, unique atmosphere, friendly staff and, of course, hot and fresh pizza. Only at Primo’s, the sauce isn’t just slathered on the top side of the crust — it’s delicately swirled on the top of the pizza for a dizzyingly delicious looking result. When you need a tasty, savory dinner that’s not quite pizza, check out their Stromboli, which York customers have dubbed the best in town.

Check out the swirled sauces and the best Stromboli in town at 1425 N. Sherman St.

5. MOD Pizza


When you crave a bit of variety and individuality, stop by MOD Pizza for a personal-sized artisan pizza. This innovative pizza concept wants to ensure you’re always treated to a pie that suits the simplest or zaniest of your tastes — choose from several crust flavors and more than 30 pizza toppings, then watch as your pizza is perfectly baked in a brick oven right before your eyes. MOD Pizza can even accommodate gluten-free diets. Get creative with your pizza and enjoy the York scenery with pleasant outdoor seating options.

Think up all of the different pizza flavor combinations you can, then visit MOD Pizza at 114 Pauline Dr. to see your creation come to life.

Looking for a New Home? Call CENTURY 21 Core Partners Today

To ensure you have the best, most personal and effective real estate services in York, PA, and beyond, contact the skilled and experienced team at CENTURY 21 Core Partners. We’ll help you with any of your home buying or selling needs and work closely with you to find property solutions that fit your needs and budget.

To learn more about our real estate services — or where we consider the best pizza places near York — call us today at 717-718-0748.

Trackback from your site.

Leave a Reply


Recent Company Testimonials

Testimonial data verified by RealSatisfied

About our blog

Our agents write often to give you the latest insights on owning a home or property in the Central PA, Northern Maryland area.